Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2024
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b5573917, PubMed ID (PMID): 3903734622. Jul 2024,Pages 277-284, Language: EnglishGemperle, Gina A. / Hamza, Blend / Patcas, Raphael / Schätzle, Marc / Wegehaupt, Florian J. / Hersberger-Zurfluh, Monika A.Purpose: This in-vitro study aimed to investigate the cleaning efficacy of 18 different manual children’s toothbrushes applying horizontal, vertical, and rotational movements, as well as to evaluate the rounding of their filament ends.
Materials and methods: Models equipped with artificial teeth (coated with titanium dioxide) were brushed using a brushing machine with clamped manual children’s toothbrushes. The machine carried out horizontal, vertical, and rotational movements for 1 min with a constant contact pressure of 100 g. The percentage of the area of titanium dioxide removed from the buccal, mesial, distal and total surfaces of the artificial teeth corresponded to the cleaning efficacy. To assess the filament design, a scanning electron microscope was used to check the morphology of the filaments which was scored with Silverstone and Featherstone scale. SPSS 22 was used for data analysis.
Results: The rotational and the vertical movements achieved the best cleaning efficacy with all tested toothbrushes. The vast majority of the tested toothbrushes had their poorest cleaning efficacy in the horizontal movement. Only a small part of the children’s toothbrushes (3 out of 18) had a correct and acceptable proportion of rounded bristle ends.
Conclusions: Based on the present results, it could be concluded that the cleaning efficacy of different manual children’s toothbrushes varied considerably. The best cleaning efficacy was almost always observed for rotational and vertical movements.
Keywords: children’s toothbrushes, cleaning, efficacy, filament end rounding, pediatric dentistry
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2023
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b4100897, PubMed ID (PMID): 3719533117. May 2023,Pages 153-162, Language: EnglishTanner, Moritz / Singh, Raphael / Svellenti, Leonardo / Hamza, Blend / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: This study investigated the effect of toothbrush bristle stiffness and brushing force on the cleaning efficacy in vitro.
Materials and Methods: Eighty bovine dentin samples were allocated to eight groups (n=10). Two custom-made toothbrushes of different bristle stiffness (soft and medium) were tested at four different brushing forces (1, 2, 3 and 4 N). Dentin samples were stained in black tea and brushed (60 strokes/min) for a total of 25 min in a brushing machine with an abrasive solution (RDA 67). Photographs were taken after 2 and 25 min of brushing time. Cleaning efficacy was measured planimetrically.
Results: After 2 min of brushing, the soft-bristle toothbrush did not cause statistically significantly different cleaning efficacy at different brushing forces, while the medium-bristle toothbrush cleaned statistically significantly less efficaceously only at 1 N. Comparing the two different toothbrushes, higher cleaning efficacy was observed only at 1 N for the soft-bristle brush. At 25 min brushing time, the soft-bristle cleaned statistically significantly better at 4 N compared to 1 N and 2 N and at 3 N compared to 1 N. Using the medium-bristle, cleaning efficacy increased with increasing brushing force. After 25 min of brushing, no statistically significant difference was observed between the two different toothbrushes.
Conclusion: Irrespective the brushing force, the use of a soft or medium toothbrush results in comparable cleaning efficacy. At 2 min brushing time, increasing the brushing force does not increase the cleaning efficacy.
Keywords: bristle stiffness, brushing force, cleaning efficacy, toothbrush
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2023
Open Access Online OnlyPeriodontologyDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b4100941, PubMed ID (PMID): 3719533317. May 2023,Pages 171-178, Language: EnglishFrey, Adrian Christian / Gubler, Andrea / Schmidlin, Patrick R. / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: To assess the root surface roughness and substance loss induced by chemical and chemomechanical challenges on root surfaces pretreated with ultrasonic instrumentation, a hand scaler, or erythritol airflow.
Materials and Methods: One hundred twenty (120) bovine dentin specimens were used in this study. Specimens were divided into eight groups and treated as follows: groups 1 and 2: polished with 2000- and 4000-grit carborundum papers but not instrumented (‘untreated’); groups 3 and 4: hand scaler; groups 5 and 6: ultrasonic instrumentation; groups 7 and 8: erythritol airflow. Samples from groups 1, 3, 5, and 7 then underwent a chemical challenge (5 x 2 min HCl [pH 2.7]), whereas samples from groups 2, 4, 6, and 8 were subjected to a chemomechanical challenge (5 x 2 min HCl [pH 2.7] + 2 min brushing). Surface roughness and substance loss were measured profilometrically.
Results: The least substance loss through chemomechanical challenge was noted after erythritol airflow treatment (4.65 ± 0.93 µm), followed by ultrasonic instrumentation (7.30 ± 1.42 µm) and the hand scaler (8.30 ± 1.38 µm); the last two (hand scaler and ultrasonic tip) did not differ statistically significantly. The highest roughness after chemomechanical challenge was observed on ultrasonically treated specimens (1.25 ± 0.85 µm), followed by hand-scaled specimens (0.24 ± 0.16 µm) and those subject to erythritol airflow (0.18 ± 0.09 µm); there was no statistically signficant difference between the latter two, but they both differed statistically significantly from the ultrasonically treated specimens. No statistically significant difference in substance loss through the chemical challenge was observed between specimens pretreated by the hand scaler (0.75 ± 0.15 µm), ultrasonic tip (0.65 ± 0.15 µm), and erythritol airflow (0.75 ± 0.15 µm). The chemical challenge smoothed the surfaces treated with the hand scaler, ultrasonic tip, and erythritol airflow.
Conclusion: Dentin pretreatment with erythritol powder airflow resulted in a higher resistance to chemomechanical challenge than did dentin treated ultrasonically or with the hand scaler.
Keywords: erythritol airflow, hand scaler, ultrasonic, substance loss, surface roughness
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2023
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b4586835, PubMed ID (PMID): 379165502. Nov 2023,Pages 391-396, Language: EnglishBlatter, Nicolai / Hamza, Blend / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian JPurpose: To investigate the effect of the supplementation of energy drinks with green tea extract on abrasive and erosive dentin wear.
Materials and Methods: Six groups, each comprising 15 bovine dentin samples, were prepared, yielding a total of 90 samples. Erosion was performed by immersing the samples in Red Bull and Red Bull light with and without green tea extract. Tap water with and without green tea extract was used as the control groups. The samples were subjected to abrasive/erosive cycling for five days. The following cycling was performed daily: toothbrush abrasion (20 brushstrokes; 2.5 N); eight erosive cycles (2 min storage in the respective solutions); in between the erosive cycles, storage in artificial saliva (60 min) and again toothbrush abrasion (20 brushstrokes; 2.5 N). During the night, samples were again stored in artificial saliva. Abrasive/erosive dentin wear was measured using a stylus profilometer (µm, accuracy = 40 nm). The measured dentin loss results from the vertical position shift on the y-axis from base to final profile after the wear process in 2D. Pairwise comparisons between the groups were carried out using Wilcoxon signed-rank test.
Results: The following dentin wear (median [IQR]) was measured: Red Bull: 1.9 µm (0.5); Red Bull Light: 1.3 µm (0.3); Red Bull with green tea extract: 0.8 µm (0.3); Red Bull Light with green tea extract: 0.3 µm (0.5); Tap water with green tea extract: -0.2 µm (0.7); Tap water: -1.0 µm (1.2). The comparison of all tested groups to each other proved to be statistically significant (p < 0.05).
Conclusion: The supplementation of energy drinks with green tea extract provide a protective effect against erosive/abrasive wear in vitro.
Keywords: abrasive dentin wear, energy drinks, erosive dentin wear, green tea, profilometry
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2023
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b3858625, PubMed ID (PMID): 367278372. Feb 2023,Pages 41-48, Language: EnglishDobler, Liana / Hamza, Blend / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: To investigate the absolute wear caused by toothpastes with highly discrepant REA (Relative Enamel Abrasivity) and RDA (Relative Dentin Abrasivity) values on both enamel and dentin: Candida Peppermint (CP; REA: 1; RDA: 42), Colgate Total Original (CTO; REA: 4; RDA: 100), Signal White System (SWS; REA: 8; RDA: 143), and Candida White Diamond (CWD; REA 244; RDA: 12).
Materials and Methods: Eighty (80) bovine enamel samples and 80 dentin samples were divided into four groups each (n = 20) and investigated after a 6-h brushing procedure (21,600 cycles, 60 cycles/min, load of 2.5 N) with the four toothpastes. The abrasive enamel and dentin wear were registered using a contact profilometer. The median and interquartile range (IQR) of the abrasive enamel and dentin wear were calculated for each group. Pairwise comparisons were conducted using the Wilcoxon signed-rank exact test, and the p-value was adjusted according to Holm (statistical significance set at 0.05).
Results: CWD led to the highest abrasive enamel wear (9.86 μm [5.77]). CTO caused the highest abrasive dentin wear (166.70 μm [69.90]), being statistically significantly higher than the wear for CP (54.20 μm [24.00]) and CWD (17.00 μm [7.80]) (p = 0.00001). The abrasive dentin wear for CWD was statistically significantly lower in comparison to all other groups (p = 0.00001).
Conclusion: Toothpastes with highly discrepant REA and RDA values presented statistically significantly different absolute wear on enamel and dentin. REA and RDA values should both be declared for every toothpaste.
Keywords: abrasive dentin wear, abrasive enamel wear, RDA, REA, toothpaste abrasivity
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2022
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b3601687, PubMed ID (PMID): 3641660323. Nov 2022,Pages 457-464, Language: EnglishZoller, Manuel J. / Lasance, Florance A. / Hamza, Blend / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: This in-vitro study deals with the question of whether the wear and tear of the manual toothbrush over a simulated timeframe up to 24 months has an effect on its cleaning performance. The purpose was to find indications as to whether and when a toothbrush needs to be replaced based on its cleaning performance.
Materials and Methods: Models equipped with artificial teeth (coated with titanium dioxide) were brushed in-vitro using a brushing machine with clamped manual toothbrushes. The machine carried out even, horizontal brush strokes (120 brush strokes/min) for 1 min with a constant contact pressure of 2.5 N. The percentage of the area of titanium dioxide removed from the buccal, mesial and distal surfaces of the artificial teeth corresponded to the cleaning performance. The manual toothbrushes were used on bovine roots to simulate the wear and tear after 2, 4, 6, 12, 18, 24 months of use. The cleaning performance was re-evaluated after each simulated timepoint of wear. In addition, the brushes were photographed after each cycle.
Results: An increase in the in-vitro cleaning performance of the toothbrush was observed up to 6 months of wear compared to the starting point. After that, the cleaning performance decreased somewhat, but always remained above the initial cleaning performance.
Conclusion: Based on the in-vitro cleaning performance after 24 months, the toothbrush would not have to be replaced. However, this in-vitro study cannot determine when a toothbrush should be replaced, because in-vivo it is also dependent on a variety of other factors such as fraying and microbial colonisation. Direct transfer of results from this study to everyday clinical practice is therefore difficult.
Keywords: cleaning, performance, toothbrush, wear and tear
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2022
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b3601691, PubMed ID (PMID): 3641660423. Nov 2022,Pages 465-474, Language: EnglishPulfer, Anina M. / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: To determine the salivary flow rate and subsequent dilution of toothpaste and assess the pH of oral fluids during toothbrushing with toothpastes of various pHs.
Materials and Methods: The study was conducted as an in-vivo trial involving 30 healthy volunteers. The participants took part in a series of trials distributed over four appointments. After a screening check, in which the participants’ stimulated and unstimulated salivary flow rate and buffering capacities were determined, four test series involving toothbrushing were conducted. Participants brushed their teeth using a manual toothbrush for 2 min: once without toothpaste and three times using toothpastes of varying pHs. The salivary flow rate and subsequent dilution of the toothpaste was determined. Additionally, the pH of the collected oral fluid was analysed.
Results: Brushing teeth with toothpaste caused a statistically significant increase in salivary flow rate (median/IQR in ml/min) (Elmex Kariesschutz 3.29/1.36, Colgate Total Original 3.23/1.08, Elmex Sensitive Professional 3.18/1.39) when compared to brushing teeth using a manual toothbrush without toothpaste (1.85/0.78) (p < 0.05). The variation in pH of the oral fluid samples was dictated primarily by the pH of the toothpaste used.
Conclusion: The salivary flow rate when brushing using toothpaste was similar across all tested toothpastes, independent of pH, and had an average median of 3.23 ml/min. The dilution of 1 g of toothpaste during a standard toothbrushing procedure of 2 min is therefore approximately at a ratio of one part toothpaste to 6.5 parts saliva.
Keywords: hydrogen ion concentration, saliva, salivary flow rate, toothbrushing, toothpastes
Quintessenz Zahnmedizin, 9/2021
Orale MedizinPages 1008-1017, Language: GermanAttin, Thomas / Körner, Philipp / Wegehaupt, FlorianDer Beitrag befasst sich mit verschiedenen Hintergründen des gehäuft beobachteten Auftretens von Zahnerosionen bei Sportlern. Er fasst Grundlagen zur Entstehung von erosiven Zahnhartsubstanzdefekten sowie besondere ätiologische Faktoren für Sportlergruppen mit erhöhter Erosionsprävalenz zusammen und schließt mit Hinweisen zur Prävention.
Keywords: Erosiver Zahnhartsubstanzverlust, Erosionen, Sportler, Risikofaktoren, Ernährung
Quintessence International, 10/2021
DOI: 10.3290/j.qi.b1981423, PubMed ID (PMID): 34664925Pages 912-919, Language: EnglishAttin, Thomas / Körner, Philipp / Wegehaupt, FlorianThe following article deals with various considerations concerning the frequently observed occurrence of dental erosion in athletes. It summarizes the basics of erosive tooth wear development as well as special etiologic factors for groups of athletes with increased prevalence of dental erosion and concludes with preventive advice. (Originally published (in German) in Quintessenz Zahnmed 2021;72:1008–1017)
Keywords: athletes, dental erosion, erosive tooth wear, nutrition, risk factors
Oral Health and Preventive Dentistry, 1/2021
Open Access Online OnlyOral HealthDOI: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b898955, PubMed ID (PMID): 3349137826. Jan 2021,Pages 51-57, Language: EnglishHartz, Julia J. / Procopio, Alessio / Attin, Thomas / Wegehaupt, Florian J.Purpose: A previous clinical study showed that the prevalence of erosive toothwear in vegetarians is statistically significantly higher than in nonvegetarians, due to the consumption of vinegar and other acidic foodstuffs. To adequately inform patients, this study investigated the erosive potential of bottled salad dressings available in Switzerland and compared it with that of orange juice.
Materials and Methods: One hundred enamel samples of bovine teeth were divided into ten groups. Samples were placed in 1 of 9 bottled salad dressings or orange juice (Granini) for 2 min. Afterwards, they were rinsed with Zürich tap water for 30 s, followed by abrasion with a toothbrush for 20 brush strokes and a toothpaste-saliva mixture. Erosive/abrasive enamel wear was determined with contact profilometry after 40 cycles.
Results: The enamel wear (median/IQR) caused by Tradition Sauce Balsamique (9.5 µm/5.3 µm), M-Classic Dressing Italiano (10.9 µm/12.3 µm), Betty Bossi Balsamico Dressing (9.4 µm/4.5 µm) and Thomy Balsamico Vinaigrette Dressing (14.2 µm/6.5 µm) was statistically significantly higher than that caused by orange juice (2.4 µm/0.8 µm). Enamel wear caused by M-Classic Dressing French Joghurt (0.2 µm/0.2 µm) and Coop Qualité & Prix French Dressing (1.2 µm/1.0 µm) was statistically significantly lower compared to that of orange juice.
Conclusions: The pure balsamico vinegar-based dressings (Italian type) showed a statistically significantly higher erosive potential than orange juice, whereas dressings containing calcium-rich products (enriched with milk and/or cream) (French-type) caused lower enamel wear than orange juice. The study shows that some bottled dressings have erosive potential even higher than orange juice and patients should be informed accordingly.
Keywords: erosion, tooth wear, salad dressings