Purpose: Fracture is a frequent complication of resinous prostheses. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of thickness on flexural strength of a resinous prosthesis containing a prosthetic tooth. Materials and Methods: Beam-shaped specimens 65-mm long, 12-mm wide, and 1, 2, 3, 4, or 6 mm in thickness were made from high-impact strength polymethyl methacrylate denture base material, each containing a resin-based molar prosthetic tooth at the center of the beam. A group of 3-mm-thick specimens without a prosthetic tooth (n = 7) were also made. Specimens were aged artificially, loaded in three-point flexure, examined fractographically, and analyzed. Results: The 1- and 2-mm-thick beams underwent considerable deformation at low loads. Maximum loads varied considerably from 0.6 kg (1-mm beams) to 38 kg (6-mm beams). The 3-, 4-, and 6-mm beam groups all underwent brittle fracture, with mean relative flexural strengths of approximately 73 MPa. Denture teeth reduced the relative flexural strength of resin beams by 0.7×. Fracture initiation sites were generally at tiny surface defects, but did not directly involve denture teeth. Denture resin fracture toughness was 3.2 MPa m1/2, and modulus of rupture was 104 MPa. Conclusion: Denture teeth substantially decreased the strength of resinous beams. Increased thickness markedly increased the load-bearing capacity of resinous beams containing denture teeth. Beams less than 2 mm in thickness with denture teeth were weakened substantially more than comparable beams of 2 mm or more in thickness. Surface finish was of critical importance. Fracture toughness was calculated fractographically, facilitating future forensic examination of clinically failed resinous prostheses.