Gingival recession treatment is one of the major clinical challenges in periodontics, and various surgical techniques have been proposed to correct it. Most of these techniques are suitable for isolated recession sites and involve harvesting an autogenous tissue graft, which increases patient morbidity and might result in inferior esthetics due to incision design. This study assessed the benefit of adding platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) to the vestibular incision subperiosteal tunneling approach (VISTA) in treating multiple gingival recession compared to using VISTA alone. A total of 41 teeth with Miller Class I and II defects were randomized in a split-mouth design. Multiple clinical parameters were tested, including the change in gingival thickness over time, keratinized tissue width, and gingival phenotype (using the transparency of a periodontal probe). Patient-centered outcomes were also assessed via visual analog scale. Multiple Miller Class I and II recessions in the maxilla can be effectively treated with VISTA. However, when used in conjunction with PRF, no significant differences were detected in any parameter. VISTA has been shown to be associated with a low level of postsurgical pain for patients and can be used for patients with high esthetic demands.